Cedar vs. Vinyl Siding: Which Is Right for Your Ontario Home?

When it comes to upgrading your home’s exterior, siding is one of the most important decisions you’ll make. Not only does it affect curb appeal, but it also plays a key role in protecting your home from the elements. At JD Wood Revival, we specialize in cedar siding installation across Ontario, and we’re often asked how it compares to vinyl siding. 

Let’s break down the pros and cons of each to help you decide what’s best for your home.

Aesthetic Appeal

Cedar Siding:
Nothing matches the natural beauty of real wood. Cedar siding brings a timeless, rustic elegance that adds warmth and character. It can be installed in various styles—shakes, shingles, or planks—and finished with stains or left to naturally weather to a soft silvery grey.

Vinyl Siding:
Vinyl is available in a wide range of colors and styles, including wood-look textures. However, even the highest-quality vinyl often lacks the authenticity and depth of real wood grain. It’s a good option if you’re looking for uniformity and a lower-maintenance aesthetic.

Verdict: If natural charm and uniqueness are important to you, cedar is the winner.

---

 

Durability & Maintenance

Cedar Siding:
Cedar is naturally resistant to rot and insects, but it does require regular maintenance – cleaning, staining or sealing every few years – to keep it looking its best and to extend its lifespan. This is a service we offer – learn more here.

Vinyl Siding:
Vinyl is low maintenance and easy to clean. It doesn’t require painting or sealing and can last 20–40 years. However, it can crack in extreme cold and may fade over time, especially in sunny areas.

Verdict: Vinyl wins on maintenance; cedar wins on resilience if properly cared for.

---

 

Environmental Impact

Cedar Siding:
Cedar is a renewable resource and biodegradable, making it one of the more environmentally friendly building materials when sourced responsibly.

Vinyl Siding:
Vinyl is made from PVC (a type of plastic), which is not biodegradable and produces more emissions during manufacturing. While it’s durable, its eco-friendliness is FAR lower than wood.

Verdict: Cedar is the clear choice for homeowners who prioritize sustainability.

---

 

Cost

Cedar Siding:
Generally more expensive upfront, both in terms of materials and labor, due to the craftsmanship involved in installation and ongoing maintenance. Learn more in this article.

Vinyl Siding:
More budget-friendly with lower installation and upkeep costs, making it attractive for homeowners on a tighter budget.

Verdict: Vinyl is more cost-effective; cedar is an investment in long-term beauty and value.

---

 

Performance in Ontario’s Climate

In Toronto, Hamilton, and the surrounding Ontario region, weather can be unpredictable—cold winters, humid summers, and plenty of moisture.

• Cedar adapts well to temperature changes but requires upkeep to protect against moisture.

• Vinyl stands up to moisture but may become brittle in freezing temperatures.

Verdict: Both perform well, but proper installation and care are critical. JD Wood Revival ensures cedar siding is expertly treated for durability in Ontario’s climate.

---

 

Which One Is Right for You?

Choose cedar siding if you:

• Love natural wood aesthetics

• Prefer eco-friendly materials

• Don’t mind regular maintenance

Choose vinyl siding if you:

• Want a low-maintenance option

• Are working with a tighter budget

• Prefer a modern, uniform look

---

Considering a Siding Upgrade in Ontario?

Whether you’re leaning toward the classic charm of cedar siding or the practicality of vinyl, JD Wood Revival can help you make the best choice for your home, and assist with the install. Contact us today for a free consultation and see how we can bring beauty and value to your exterior.